| Watchindia.TV brings you the best of Indian television live from India! evonyonline.com," Come Play, my Lord" |
|
|
|
|
Somalia: Donor caution alarms aid workers
Friday 6 November 2009 SMC
Aid agencies operating in Somalia say they need more money but that some donors are holding back, concerned at where resources might end up in areas too dangerous for international staff.
"Some of the largest donors in 2008 have given much less or almost no support so far this year," said Kiki Gbeho, head of UN Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs (OCHA) for Somalia.
Large parts of Islamist rebel-dominated southern and central Somalia are classified as just below the worst "famine" level on a five-point scale used by food security analysts. Aid planners are considering where needy people might move, in or out of the country, and where aid could be delivered securely.
As of November 2009, total available humanitarian funding for Somalia stands at US$571 million, compared with $615 million in 2008 (according to the OCHA-managed Financial Tracking System). However, this masks the fact that over $215 million was carried over from unspent or late 2008 monies.
Gbeho warned that if the funding situation did not improve soon, it could have a negative impact on the whole region, as fleeing Somalis sought relief not only within safer areas of Somalia as but in neighbouring countries too.
"According to one worst-case scenario, an additional 283,000 Somalis could flee to neighbouring countries and would require assistance," Gbeho said. "Already, 530,000 Somali refugees live in several countries in the region."
The lukewarm and unpredictable donor response, senior aid workers and observers told IRIN, is due at least in part to perceptions that aid operations cannot be properly supervised in areas controlled by armed groups, including Al-Shabab, which might steal or "tax" the aid or benefit indirectly. Some donors feel it is hard to provide the "due diligence" their taxpayers deserve and doubt "remote control" management and monitoring techniques. This comes on top of budget pressures due to the global financial crisis, observers say.
The World Food Programme is conducting an internal investigation in response to allegations that some of its relief supplies are being diverted away from their intended beneficiaries.
Britain's Department for International Development (DFID), is "very concerned about allegations of humanitarian food aid being sold for profit in Somalia. Any future contributions to the WFP will be in the light of the findings of the investigation into the alleged misuse of aid," according to a spokesman.
"We are committed to helping the people of Somalia, and this year alone we will provide £23 million to tackle hunger, and provide healthcare and education," he said.
"Donor countries have to be careful with the money they give to Somalia," a western diplomat, who requested anonymity, said. "There is a problem with lack of proper monitoring inside the country, due to the prevailing security situation... There is also the fear in some quarters that some of the money is ending up in the wrong hands."
Aid agencies argue that even in dangerous areas, brave and dedicated local staff, creative partnerships and networks involving local NGOs and community leadership can and do deliver successful life-saving programmes. A combination of appropriate monitoring techniques, they say, offers fully credible accountability.
According to OCHA, 42 humanitarian aid workers have been killed since January 2008 and 10 remain in captivity, and very few international staff stay continuously in south-central Somalia -while some areas are off-limits even to national staff.
Alun McDonald of Oxfam, while admitting that access was a problem, given the lack of security and functioning government, said: "But just because it's difficult, that's not an excuse to stop aid when 3.6 million people need assistance. We stress to donors that we work with trusted and long-term local partners, with regular monitoring visits from Oxfam staff, and we are confident that aid is being delivered appropriately," he added.
"We can respond, despite the situation," insisted another aid official. Unrealistic conditions being floated by some donors to try to limit risk would make it impossible even to get "from point A to point B" in areas controlled by militants, the official added.
US humanitarian funding has been tangled much of the year in anti-terrorism legislation, affecting its ability to contribute food and cash. Nevertheless it has still been the largest humanitarian donor in 2009. A US State Department spokesperson told IRIN an ongoing review on US aid to Somalia "will include ensuring compliance with US laws designed to prevent potential support to terrorists".
Private non-governmental donations have become the second biggest source of donations reported to the FTS (see BOX). Aid officials say concerns about accountability have influenced donors, but concerns have not been publicly articulated.
The fact that some channels of funding have not diminished in 2009, such as governance support to the fledgling TFG, assistance to the African Union's peacekeeping force and even in direct weapons transfers to the government, has left some NGOs nonplussed. "Transferring guns seems a lot more risky than food and water," commented one aid worker.
UN Under-Secretary-General Lynn Pascoe in late October hinted at a chicken and egg situation when he said: "I would guess that we will be asking for more money and more assistance in the months ahead. Clearly they're going to need it both for security and also for the social services the government needs to provide. One of the difficulties about
Somalia, of course, is that without the aid and the assistance for real development aid, it's very hard for the government to show what it's doing."
Meanwhile, further narrowing humanitarian space, local media reported this week a spokesperson for Al-Shabab has announced that aid carrying the US flag would be banned in areas under its control.
Some argue that not funding humanitarian operations would strengthen, not weaken, armed militant groups. In spite of the risk of aid diversion, donors must not reduce their levels of humanitarian assistance, the UN Secretary-General's Special Representative on the rights of displaced people urged last month. Walter Kälin told journalists: "This would not only mean punishing the most vulnerable among already destitute communities, but also playing into the hands of radical elements who could easily exploit the situation."
Aid agencies are putting the finishing touches on the consolidated humanitarian appeal for 2010, for release early December. A well-placed official said funding will be "even more tricky next year".
Source: IRIN News
Somaliweyn Media Center “SMC”
 |
|
 |
Arabic News
Today's
News 17-June-2009 |
تشهد العاصمة الصومالية إشتباكات عنيفة ومؤتمرالعالم الإسلامي يعلن أن التحالف مع الأجانب لا يناقض الولاء والبراء
(Reads
more) 17-June-
2009
حركة الشباب المجاهدين تسيطر علي كبري مدن إقليم شبلي الوسطي في جنوب الصومال
(Read
more) 17-may-
2009
مقتل خمسة وإصابة عشرة بعد سقوط قذيفة مدفعية علي مدرسة لتحفيظ القرآن الكريم في وسط مقديشو
(Read
more) 17-may-
2009
الأمم المتحدة لن ترسل قوات الى الصومال قريبا
(Read
more) 16-may-
2009
سكان العاصمة الصومالية يواصلون النزوح خشية تجدد المعارك
(Read
more) 16-may-
2009
الحكومة الصومالية تعلن محاولة حسن طاهر أويس بلإطاحة بشيخ شريف
(Read
more) 14-may-
2009
المحاكم الإسلامية تعلن حقهم الشرعي في الدفاع عن أنفسهم في العاصمة أو في الأقاليم الصومالية
(Read
more) 14-may-
2009
شبكة جواسيس تتيح للقراصنة الصوماليين اختطاف السفن
(Read
more) 14-may-
2009
رئيس الجمهورية الصومالية يصادق علي تطبيق الشريعة وحركة الشباب تستولي علي مناطق جديدة
(Read
more) 13-may-
2009
حركة الشباب تواصل إرسال المزيد من قواتها العسكرية إلي العاصمة الصومالية
(Read
more) 13-may-
2009
حركة الشباب تحذر من تسمية المجاهدين المسلمين بأجانب
(Read
more) 12-may-
2009
إقليم هيران يشهد إشتباكات بين قوات الإثيوبية وفصائل الإسلامية
(Read
more) 12-may-
2009
الحزب الإسلامي يغلق ١٠ شركات للحوالة في مدينة أفقوي عاصمة إقليم شبلي الوسطي
(Read
more) 12-may-
2009
البحرية الفرنسية تسلم 11 صوماليا متهمين بالقرصنة للقضاء الكيني
(Read
more) 11-may-
2009
شيخ شريف يتهم المعارضة بتنفيذ مخططات ومصالح اجنبية في الصومال
(Read
more) 11-may-
2009
هيئة علماء الصومال تصدر بيان ختاميى بشأن الوضع الصومالي
(Read
more) 11-may-
2009
الشعب الصومالي بين مطرقة الفصائل الإسلامية وسندان عجز الحكومة الإنتقالية
(Read
more) 09-may-
2009
العاصمة الصومالية تشهد إشتباكات عنيفة ليومها الثالث أدت لمقتل العديد من المدنيين
(Read
more) 09-may-
2009
العاصمة الصومالية تشهد إشتباكات عنيفة ليومها الثالث أدت لمقتل العديد من المدنيين
(Read
more) 09-may-
2009
قاض أمر بالافراج عن سبعة قراصنة صوماليين مفترضين في اسبانيا
(Read
more) 09-may-
2009
البحرية الفرنسية تسلم 11 قرصانا آخر مشتبه بهم الى كينيا
(Read
more) 09-may-
2009
العاصمة الصومالية تشهد إشتباكات عنيفة ليومها الثاني
(Read
more) 08-may-
2009
اعتقال 7 قراصنة صوماليين واختطاف سفينة هولندية في خليج عدن
(Read
more) 08-may-
2009
طائرة اماراتية تصل الى مطار بربرة على متنها 35 طنا من المساعدات للشعب الصومالي ./ إضافة ثانية.
(Read
more) 08-may-
2009
قراصنة يطلقون النيران على سفينة للبحرية الأمريكية أمام الصومال
(Read
more) 07-may-
2009
منظمة ملاحية: قراصنة صوماليون يحتجزون سفينة هولندية
(Read
more) 07-may-
2009
مقتل مدني واصابة اكثر من ٥٠ شخصا في موجهات بين القوات المحاكم الاسلامية وحركة الشباب في العاصمة الصومالية مقديشو
(Read
more) 07-may-
2009 |
English News
Today's
News 1-November-2009 |
6 soldiers died in a landmine explosion in Lasanod town
(Read more) 1-Nov-2009
Somalia: 112-year-old man marries 17-year-old girl (Read more) 1-Nov-2009
Today's
News 31-October-2009 |
Al-Shabab says they will attack Asmara (Read more) 31-Oct-2009
Government rebels fight in Tayeglow district (Read more) 31-Oct-2009
6 people died in a road accident 22 others wounded (Read more) 31-Oct-2009
Somali pirates say they hijacked Yemeni vessel (Read more) 31-Oct-2009
Pirates Seek $7 Million for British Couple (Read more) 31-Oct-2009
Today's
News 30-October-2009 |
Are the Antelopes and the Ostriches of Somalia Pirates? (Read more) 30-Oct-2009
Senior U.S. Official for Refugees Concludes Africa Visit (Read more) 30-Oct-2009
The Reform Agenda and Kenya’s Historic Opportunity
Speech to the Law Society of Kenya (Read more) 30-Oct-2009
Weekly Humanitarian Bulletin 23 Oct-30 Oct (Read more) 30-Oct-2009
Today's
News 29-October-2009 |
Yemen Arrests 6 Suspected Qaeda Africans (Read more) 29-Oct-2009
39 illegal foreigners mostly Somalis arrested in South Africa (Read more) 29-Oct-2009
Militants can't attack Uganda – Somalia envoy (Read more) 29-Oct-2009
Today's
News 28-October-2009 |
President Shariff is back home from Arab Countries (Read more) 28-Oct-2009
Somali pirates seized after firing on French ship (Read more) 28-Oct-2009
Somali PM says his country is haven for Al-Qaeda (Read more) 28-Oct-2009
Open Letter to H.E President Obama (Read more) 28-Oct-2009
Somalia moving forward, more money needed, UN says (Read more) 28-Oct-2009
Today's
News 27-October-2009 |
Hizbul-Islam disarm Sheikh Abdirahman Moaw
(Read more) 27-Oct-2009
WFP Transport Contractor Decries Baseless Accusations of Misappropriation... (Read more) 27-Oct-2009
British couple hijacked by Somali pirates (Read more) 27-Oct-2009
10 mln internally displaced in east, central Africa (Read more) 27-Oct-2009
Today's
News 26-October-2009 |
For peace in Bujumbura and Kampala troops should be pulled out (Al-Shabab) (Read more) 26-Oct-2009
Ugandan Somalis distance themselves from Al Shabaab (Read more) 26-Oct-2009
Soldier jailed over Somalia affair (Read more) 26-Oct-2009
The inhabitants of Dhusamareb asked to register their arms (Read more) 26-Oct-2009
Puntland administration sentence 12 pirates (Read more) 26-Oct-2009
Djibouti says Eritrea arming, training militias (Read more) 26-Oct-2009
Today's
News 25-October-2009 |
Islamists send warning signal to Kenya and Djibouti (Read more) 25-Oct-2009
Youngsters gunned down for Espionage reasons-say Al-Shabab (Read more) 25-Oct-2009
Museveni warns Somali Islamists (Read more) 25-Oct-2009
UN political chief calls for increased world support in push for peace (Read more) 25-Oct-2009
Today's
News 24-October-2009 |
Stop Recruitment of Somalis in Refugee Camps (Read more) 24-Oct-2009
Weekly Humanitarian Bulletin 16 Oct-23 Oct (Read more) 24-Oct-2009
PSU Institutional Capacity Building
Conference in Minnesota (Read more) 24-Oct-2009
Obama offers millions in Muslim technology fund (Read more) 24-Oct-2009
Washington D.C Metropolitan Area Somali Community welcomed Mrs. Asha Haji Elmi, winner of 2009
(Read more) 24-Oct-2009
Today's
News 21-October-2009 |
Ambassador Noor Ade Visits 2 regions in Italy
(Read more) 22-Oct-2009
Somalia: Daybreak bombardment in Mogadishu kills 23 (Read more) 22-Oct-2009
President Shariff denies, Military Commander Dhumal proves!! (Read more) 22-Oct-2009
Djibouti Rejects Alleged Destabilization Role in Somalia (Read more) 22-Oct-2009
Today's
News 21-October-2009 |
 |
The King of KSA sent congratulation latter to President Shariff (Read more) 21-Oct-2009 |
Foreign Vessels in the Somali waters are hazardous than Pirates says - Qanyare (Read more) 21-Oct-2009
Kadhafi receives Somali maritime organisation delegation (Read more) 21-Oct-2009
Al-Shabab martyrs closedown 2 independent radio stations in Bay region (Read more) 21-Oct-2009
Protest against the writings for the masters of deceit (Read more) 21-Oct-2009
2010 terror plot: 'SA not ready' (Read more) 21-Oct-2009
Today's
News 19-October-2009 |
Unmanned secret agent plane shoot down in Kisamyo town (Read more) 19-Oct-2009
The last Al-Shabab martyrs’ amputation victim has expired (Read more) 19-Oct-2009
Government displays corpses to the press (Read more) 19-Oct-2009
2 prominent brothers gunned down in Baladweyn town (Read more) 19-Oct-2009
Long Lethargy (Read more) 19-Oct-2009
A convey of AU troops comes under explosion in Mogadishu (Read more) 19-Oct-2009
Chinese ship hijacked in Indian Ocean: EU (Read more) 19-Oct-2009
France asks Seychelles to help with pirate trials (Read more) 19-Oct-2009
Shabaab rebels destroy grave and mosque in Somalia (Read more) 19-Oct-2009
Today's
News 18-October-2009 |
Pupils awarded with bombs and riffles (Read more) 18-Oct-2009
Illegal Immigration (Tahriib); a Journey through Hell without Hope!!! (Read more) 18-Oct-2009
Today's
News 17-October-2009 |
 |
Alshabaab—“If Your Breasts Ain’t Bouncing, You Must Get Whipped” (Read more) 17-Oct-2009 |
“The Somali local Press is gagged” say AU spokesman
(Read more) 17-Oct-2009
Radicals recruiting young Somalis in Kenya-parents
(Read more) 17-Oct-2009
President Shariff back in Mogadishu after his first trip to the USA
(Read more) 17-Oct-2009
New militants of Hizbul-Islam join Somali government (Read more) 17-Oct-2009
Weekly Humanitarian Bulletin 9 Oct-16 Oct (Read more) 17-Oct-2009
“No reopening of the ocean demarcation” speaker of the House (Read more) 17-Oct-2009
Somalia Humanitarian Overview September 2009 (Read more) 17-Oct-2009
FSNAU and FEWSNET Somalia Market Data Update September 2009 (Read more) 17-Oct-2009
|
Somaliweyn Media Center (SMC)
Muqdisho Somalia
Somaliweyn Media Center (SMC)
|
